Monogatari S2 – Episode 12

New arc! Man has this season been some good Monogatari. I think Neko Shiro is probably my single favorite arc of the show to date, and Araragi-Shinobu: Time-Traveling Zombie-Fighting Buddy Cops isn’t far behind. I’ve written more about this goddamn series than any other by a fairly significant margin, but it’s generally been a show I found more interesting than fully coherent – the style of storytelling was very unique, and the tricks of direction were extremely compelling, but it didn’t necessarily gel into a cohesive production. This season has blown that complaint away, telling vivid and compelling stories that don’t lean on either Isin’s wordplay or Shinbo’s cinematography, but instead make best use of each of their strengths in tandem. And now we have the Nadeko arc.

This is gonna be interesting. In Bake, I felt her arc was basically a biting, caustic comment by Shinbo, but Nadeko herself didn’t really have any presence. These first two arcs have been well-written and well-directed, but they’ve also had the benefit of leaning on two of the Monogatari universe’s strongest variables, Hanekawa herself and the Araragi-Shinobu relationship. Since Nadeko is so loosely define, this arc could go basically anywhere. So let’s go on an adventure.

Episode 12

0:52 – Ominous. Also, they really did pick the worst possible show to do this goddamn simulcast for. Pausing and rewinding for the stills is just ridiculous

[Commie] Monogatari Series Second Season - 10 [34C8F5C8].mkv_snapshot_00.37_[2014.01.02_00.00.11]

1:49 – Seriously, this player is making me resent what a gifted cinematographer Shinbo is 

2:14 – Hey, look, identity stuff. Good to see you again, Isin

2:38 – Another version of the shrine. Getting great mileage out of that one threatening light

3:45 – This scene is one hell of a teaser. Of course the rest of the episode will be Nadeko deciding which shoes to wear to school three days ago or something

3:55 – Shinobu brings her own lighting 

[Commie] Monogatari Series Second Season - 10 [34C8F5C8].mkv_snapshot_03.48_[2014.01.02_00.06.00]

4:20 – So? If the snake is to be believed, we’re all collections of people, after all 

5:30 – Whatever your thoughts on this show, you have to admit it has some striking images 

5:51 – She’s taking back the steps she took forward in Renai Circulation. In Monogatari, even the OPs are meta-comments

6:22 – Another direct callback 

[Commie] Monogatari Series Second Season - 10 [34C8F5C8].mkv_snapshot_06.12_[2014.01.02_00.15.31]

7:20 – Another story from the girl’s perspective. Hanekawa was easily an interesting-enough character to handle the lead role (in fact, that was one of my favorite things about that arc), but we’ll have to see if Nadeko can do the same

8:15 – Hello again. Still not sure where they’re going with her

8:54 – Well that’s interesting. And she was intentionally emphasizing Nadeko’s name, when it seems like Nadeko feels totally isolated. Positioning herself as a catalyst. Veeery interesting

9:08 – Oshino, huh? Well then

9:29 – Yes, very trustworthy. 

[Commie] Monogatari Series Second Season - 10 [34C8F5C8].mkv_snapshot_09.21_[2014.01.02_00.18.08]

9:46 – I was gonna say she seems to be treating this all as a narrative she exists outside of, but Isin of course points and giggles at his own ideas

9:56 – The uniform not fitting at all is a nice touch. She’s a spy, but she’s not very good at it

10:08 – Another meta comment. Apparitions are very rarely pure antagonists, they’re generally just reflections of their target’s own psychology

10:17 – Is this more important regarding identity or agency? Clearly this a girl whose every line is worth paying attention to

10:35 – Substantial shift in the lighting. Reappearance of that blinding single light source from the opening. Also “sometimes people are the victim and sometimes they are the wrongdoer” definitely orients this on the identity line the opening was proposing

[Commie] Monogatari Series Second Season - 10 [34C8F5C8].mkv_snapshot_10.27_[2014.01.02_00.21.24]

11:22 – Isin likes talking about stories as much as he likes writing them

11:55 – Well, there was that prolonged hypnotism shot. What is that girl’s game?

12:07 – Lovely shot. Shinbo’s got a whole new school to design, so of course he designs it to create a moment like this

12:32 – Interesting choice. All the characters are basically alone in this world, but this is the first time we’ve seen actual strangers, which might be because Nadeko is the only one who feels alone

[Commie] Monogatari Series Second Season - 10 [34C8F5C8].mkv_snapshot_12.25_[2014.01.02_00.24.55]

12:55 – Nice effect. Shinbo definitely knows how to manage these monologues

13:40 – That speech got to her, I guess. Funny that an Araragi arc can start with a monologue by her and Araragi will just think “Jeez, did that mean something, or was she just making a weird joke? Eh, forget it,” whereas Nadeko’s whole arc might very well hinge on how she was affected by that criticism

14:35 – I wish my middle school had sweet pneumatic tube walkways

15:07 – It really is a great effect 

16:07 – Another very nicely framed shot. I like the color symmetries, and how Nadeko’s phone is deliberately separated from the rest

[Commie] Monogatari Series Second Season - 10 [34C8F5C8].mkv_snapshot_15.58_[2014.01.02_00.30.11]

17:16 – Looove these shots. The quick jumps, the lack of focus. Her anxiety comes through loud and clear

We also might be assembling some clues here. It seems that with both the charms and this current snake, Nadeko is portraying her personal desires as some antagonist forcing her in specific directions. Avoiding responsibility for her own needs. It won’t necessarily go there, but it certainly fits with the “victim” stuff

17:39 – I was worried about Nadeko carrying an arc, but I guess I shouldn’t have been. This “did I say something awkward? I’m sorry, I’m sorry, I’m sorry” rings pretty goddamn true.

18:28 – Another point in “can’t assign responsibility to herself”’s favor

19:03 – And pretty much confirmed 

19:27 – Never get tired of these 

[Commie] Monogatari Series Second Season - 10 [34C8F5C8].mkv_snapshot_19.20_[2014.01.02_00.33.05]

20:32 – Oh dear 

Again with that “once you see the apparition, you’re doomed” from Tiger. But the apparitions are obviously manifestations of subconscious problems, so…

21:29 – This one might be outside of Araragi’s pay grade

21:36 – Striking images ahoy 

22:06 – She’s now in the Circulation color scheme. Please don’t ask me what that could possibly signify

22:16 – That light again

[Commie] Monogatari Series Second Season - 10 [34C8F5C8].mkv_snapshot_22.05_[2014.01.02_00.35.13]

And Done

Strong first episode! Fast-paced, some really nicely portrayed characters moments, many arresting shots, and plenty to dig into both visually and narratively. I like this theme of victimhood and responsibility we’re apparently focusing on, and I really like how they’re portraying Nadeko’s anxiety. Extremely on board for this one.

2 thoughts on “Monogatari S2 – Episode 12

  1. >> the ending to this story was already determined back then.

    In the interview that is recorded in Bakemonogatari’s official guide book……
    Nisio Isin: I have a question that I want to ask as well. In the future, what sort of characters does Hanazawa-san wish to tackle?
    Hanazawa: I wish to take on the role of those characters with a very bad personality. As I had not acted for a really evil character before, I wish to challenge that at least once.
    Nisio Isin: I understand. Then in the future, the series will have an evil girl added to it, so please be her voice actress as well. Or, I can write Nadeko as an evil girl – such a plot isn’t too bad either.
    Hanazawa: Which means to say that she will become ‘Dark Nadeko’. *laughs* Please do that.

    Based HanaKana. My body is ready.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *