With the season cooling down, we got an episode of Oregairu that actually felt more like a season one episode – that same somewhat uneven mix of archetypal stuff and really smart, poignant character stuff. Haruno is basically a big mean-spirited wrecking ball here, who seems to more or less represent what Hachiman would become if he stayed bitter and insular and emotionally distant. If Yukino and her friends were older, they wouldn’t be made so insecure by her petty tricks, but they aren’t, and so insecurities abound. I’d honestly be fine with the final episode just being Sensei shaking Haruno by the shoulders and then telling her students not to listen to her, but I’m guessing things won’t resolve quite as simply as that.
Here’s my full episode review, and you can check out the notes below!
Ugh, Haruno
“Nothing’s changed. And she thinks that’s fine. That’s part of what makes her cute, but it’s what I can’t stand about her.” Haruno is a very cruel sibling
“If it’s not trust, then what is it?” This is nice. Hikki said “I don’t think it’s trust” initially, but that was just a vague Hachiman-ism. When Haruno actually runs with it, he ends up asking her what she means
“At the very least, I wouldn’t call it the real thing”
Valentine’s Day approaches
All the way back to the first episode, when Yui wanted help making chocolates
And again we get “why’d you leave first?”
Yui being positive about her friends treasuring their current time, of course. In contrast to what Hikki has struggled with all season
“Do you have any free days coming up?” Dang, Hikki!
Yukino diagnoses Hayato’s refusal to accept chocolates – because it would cause social problems. Everyone’s Hayato to the end
Also Iroha has decided she’s part of the club now
“Okay, then I guess you’ll do, senpai.”
Yumiko’s being too stereotypically tsun here, I think. The whole episode is a bit heavy-handed
And now even Saki arrives, and is being tsun about chocolate
Yumiko and Saki each doing the delinquent “AHHH?” at each other is pretty great
Yeah, really leaning on the gap moe with Saki. This episode is pretty dang light novel
And Yui being flustered about chocolate in a really obvious way
Hachiman giving advice on how to “trick” Hayato into accepting chocolate that’s really going to be used on him
Oh my god, Iroha’s going to use the student council to plan a chocolate testing event
Oh no it’s buzzword dude
And Haruno is the special instructor? Yeah, this episode’s pretty contrived
“Senpai, do you dislike sweet things like this?” Iroha is incorrigible
EVERYONE GETTIN’ FLUSTERED ABOUT HIKKI goddamnit
“Speaking of, Yukino gave chocolate to you once, didn’t she, Haruto?” Haruno stirring shit up as usual
This situation was designed to defuse the drama of giving chocolates, but it’s also resulted in everyone being together in the same room, where things could get heated if someone messes with them. And they invited Haruno
Things get tense between Yukino and Hikki, and Yui defuses them
But then she frowns, because she’s just helping them
“You’re a guy who doesn’t really get much. The people you’re involved with don’t really get much, either.”
“I don’t particularly feel like I’ve grown”
“Are times like these your ‘real thing?’” In contrast to Sensei’s empathetic lessons, Haruno is the gleeful sledgehammer
“Are you that boring?”
“Haruno attacks me with the things that I always want to avoid thinking about.”
“It’s not trust. It’s something more cruel… something repulsive.”
Yukino’s mom laying into her in front of her friends
“‘Who we are’ is always clashing with us somehow.”
Hey bobduh,
Loved reading your write-up/review as always. I think my interpretation of Haruno’s intentions are different from yours. Here’s more or less what I posted in the /r/anime thread:
“I don’t think Haruno is as malicious as others in this thread are saying. I think she actually cares for Yukino and Hachiman, but she also has a very dominant and controlling personality. B/c of this her interventional strategy is manipulative and antagonizing–not totally unlike Hachiman’s strategies in the beginning of the series. Right now she is frustrated that Hachiman and Yukino (and Yui, though I don’t think she cares much about her) are hiding from their true feelings and putting up a facade despite their claims to want something genuine.”
I’m not saying that Haruno is similar to Hachiman, only that, like Hachiman, her way of solving problems is flawed, even if the intentions behind her actions are good. Anyway, let me know what you think!
J
Oh, what to do. I agree with what you said and what Bobduh said. Haruno is a jerk but she’s just want them to be honest with each other, but it’s better to do it in a nicer way just like sensei did.
This episode definitely leaned more on the LN shenanigans compared to the rest of S2. However, there were a few moments where Yui seemed to be introspective about her role and the expectations placed on her that seemed interesting.
Also, have you seen this yet? It’s a translation of an interview with one of Oregairu’s producers – https://kyakka.wordpress.com/2015/06/15/oregairu-zoku-random-interview/