New Mononagatari arc! And this one… well, it sure is an Araragi arc. This was definitely one of the weakest arcs of the show so far – it did attempt to push Araragi’s narrative forward, but accomplished very little within its four episodes, and mainly spent time explaining a story that just didn’t have that much resonance to it. Araragi is far from my favorite Monogatari character, but he can still work well when he’s given the right companions to riff off of. Here, where most of his conversations were either with the straight-laced Kagenui or blank Yotsugi, that really wasn’t possible. The best part of this arc was the final confrontation with Tadatsuru, but that was a small consolation for an arc with little else to recommend it. Hopefully this fall’s arcs are more rewarding!
You can check out my full review over at ANN, or my crazy pile of notes below! These notes actually start with notes from when I was first planning to watch this arc, but held off because I knew I’d do it for review, so the first episode has a mix of timestamp writeups from a while back and current notes!
Episode 1
0:30 – Yotsugi’s a doll. An apparition
0:41 – “She’s an apparition. Hopelessly incompatible with human society.”
Lovely backgrounds for both the Shinobu and Yotsugi segments – the lighting and colors each reflect their own fundamental aesthetic and personality
0:58 – “In her structure, she resembles that of a human. She pretends to be a human.” Liars
1:16 – “The fact that she pretends to be a human is proof she isn’t trying to be one.”
1:43 – It’s not about becoming human. It’s about interacting with them, being together with them
2:17 – “The apparition exists because humans exist.” This seems like an extension of the prior “apparitions need humans to give them form” into the further “apparitions base themselves on human nature.” Both in appearance and actions?
2:22 – “This doesn’t mean they’re dependent on humans. It just means that if there is nobody to observe, nobody is being observed. Even I, who was dubbed a legendary vampire… without that legend, I would not be a vampire.” Thus she speaks in myth-making when she describes her own history
“A ghost story must be mysterious”
2:54 – When you dig down, an apparition is just a devotion
What a great line
3:26 – “Sympathy for something other than humans exists all over the world. That is why ghost stories are told.”
Cute Yotsugi costumes. And that shot of her underwater is gorgeous
4:30 – If ghost stories are spoken of too much, they become mere chitchat. The feeling disappears
4:45 – I wonder how much longer things like this will continue. I am slightly fed up with it.
4:56 – “The luxury that it will exist forever… such a thing does not exist in this world.”
5:21 – “That is why this is the beginning of the end.”
“A story about how I, Koyomi Araragi, am going to end and begin. That’s this story.” Because one Araragi must end for another to begin, for him to grow up
Really great, classic Monogatari-style OP this time
I like these cut-paper title images
Nice animation for the fire sisters waking up Araragi again
Hatred of alarm clocks
Araragi distracting himself from thinking about college entrance exams by silly banter
Again, the color scheme of the bedroom compliments Karen’s outfit
Goddamnit, Araragi’s doing the Tsukihi OP dance
“Don’t you think it’s a waste to see that talent of Karen’s get squandered away?”
Karen will quit the fire sisters, but stay in her dojo. Time passes, we change in some ways, but not in others
11:54 – Talking about Karen “retiring from the fire sisters.” The sister scenes are generally pretty pointless, but they do reflect on whatever the arc’s actually about. Like a fanservice version of the shadow girls from Utena
12:10 – Some things change, some things stay the same
12:15 – “I don’t know how my college entrance exams will go.” Focusing on the clock. This episode opens with Araragi obsessing over an alarm clock, and now we see why – he feels that time is working against him, that an era is ending, and he’s not sure he’s ready
The Araragi household’s ridiculous bathroom
Big ol’ fanservice scene
Solid animation, at least
This bathroom sure is beautiful
They can’t avoid being aware of each other’s physicality. A classic Monogatari moment
The camera gets more neutral when they stay in neutral conversation space
This is actually a pretty cute argument
A new kinda low-key song – sounds like a recorder, harmonica, and xylophone
Tsukihi’s hair is incredibly long – she’s stayed in one stage for a long time, but she’s comfortable with it
The character art is looking more expressive and beautiful than ever
18:33 – “All I could say in response to Nadeko being released from the hospital was ‘I see.’ I had no qualifications to say anything else.”
Also talking about hair cutting – if you do it poorly, it gets in your eyes and hurts. Hair cutting obviously has its own specific meaning in Monogatari, and Araragi’s on the verge of one
19:20 – Tsukihi chastising Araragi for carrying too much weight
19:55 – Apparently Nadeko’s shenanigans have once again made the town unstable. Like with Shinobu in the past, I assume – having a god in town has attracted other apparitions
“I’ll regret leaving town without solving that issue.” Changes in life stages don’t come with a convenient “level clear” marker for what you were previously going through
20:11 – “Even if everything doesn’t turn out fine, I have to make sure there is good balance here.”
20:32 – “It’s not like you can solve anything and everything, big brother.”
Beautiful shots from above
The overt fanservice shots have stopped, unsurprisingly
“Is this really the time to be washing your sister in the bath?” Lol, drawing direct attention to how Araragi’s perversion represents his youth
22:45 – Araragi’s not showing up in the mirror
25:14 – Araragi’s fear is that he’s turned into a vampire. That he’s grown into something he didn’t want to be, something he’s been dancing around being
“If you pretend to be something, that becomes the truth” is key in Monogatari, and that interacts awkwardly with Araragi’s desire to put his spirit-hunting days behind him. He can’t just want to grow up – he has to already act the part he wants to be
Relevant ED again: “Even if we can never go back to those days again…”
Episode 2
Very sharp contrasts in the colors – in comparison to Hana’s beautifully painted compositions, these are more stark and modern-styled
Aaand a kiss setup. Wonderful
Nice stained-glass image
Usual old Araragi slapstick
“Shinobu, wake up!”
Shinobu confirms Araragi has turned into a vampire. Again, worrying about what he’s becoming, fretting about the specifics
More lighting, color schemes
“Well, it’s for certain that there’s some change going on in your body right now”
When Shinobu suggests he consult Yotsugi, the color scheme changes from Shinobu’s deep reds and shadows to Yotsugi’s bright, childlike daytime colors
Araragi overacting like usual
Araragi goes to call Gaen in order to get in contact with Yotsugi, and sees she’s already texted him arranging the meeting
Dang, a crazy spinning sepia shot as Araragi tells Tsukihi to stay with Kanbaru to protect her from Yotsugi’s master
Yotsugi as a prize in a crane game. Candy-colored backgrounds
This Yotsugi crane sequence is part cute, part very sad
“Is there anything more important than getting a little girl?”
She’s doing “Yay” right now
Aw shit, Kagenui Ononoki’s there too
“Then, Araragi, while Yotsugi is analyzing the taste of your foot…” The jokes can work! This is definitely a joke-heavy arc, though
Fortunately a lot of the jokes are immediate, and not indulgent referential humor
Kagenui breaks his fingers to test his healing factor
“Believe you can heal those fingers”
Healing his fingers with the power of Hanekawa’s breasts
“Just how entrenched in adolescence are you?”
Looking at them through a blue forest of wreckage from the old burned building
Shinobu comes out his shadow dressed like a disney princess in a castle
Kagenui provoking Shinobu
Shinobu’s fragile pride. Her and Araragi are pretty important to each other
Meta self-awareness, as usual
His body is slowly turning into that of a vampire
“I think you’ve racked up stupidity, not experience”
Araragi turned into a vampire too many times – getting himself involved in too many incidents has caused this situation. Finally consequences for his actions
“You got too accustomed to turning into a vampire”
The Nadeko case was the worst. And that was the case where Araragi felt the most responsible
“How do I turn back into a human?” “Impossible. There’s no way to fix this.”
Episode 3
A couple more CG images – a glass falling, etc
Once he heard the answer, it was easy to accept. He just wanted an answer
“I should have to pay compensation for what I’ve done”
They can stop it from progressing any further
“There is a method to keep the status quo” Which seems thematically opposed to this arc
He has to stop using his powers
Jeez, some gorgeous background shots with a black moon
If he turns into a vampire anymore, Kagenui says she’ll have to kill him. And Shinobu makes a counter-threat
Yotsugi, instead of threats, asks him to promise as a friend that he’ll never become a vampire again. She knows him better – she knows he can’t let a friend now
More great compositions with the black moon and white powerlines
He promises. “That’s a pretty shallow oath”
This episode is making nice use of consistent stained-glass style tapestries
And a nice alternate artstyle for explaining what his sisters are doing
Asking Kagenui about her reasons for hunting immortal apparitions
Tadatsuru Teori, another specialist, also hunts immortal apparitions
His sisters are in trouble, stolen by Tadatsuru
This arc is a bit too plot-heavy, and doesn’t star characters who have the most interesting chemistry. Spoiled by Kanbaru and Kaiki
Now they’re talking in a decaying castle
Araragi talking about how he deserves this punishment – like before, he’s taking everything upon himself
Kagenui says the timing is too suspicious. This was all set up
Tadatsuru thinks he’s an artist – he thinks apparitions are beautiful
Shinobu and Yotsugi having a random snowball fight with some actual animation
Kagenui and Araragi talking in an ice castle
Episode 4
Ougi’s waiting for them when they arrive, of course
Ougi’s been waiting there since the morning, since obviously she knew that’s where he’d end up
“Where’s Shinobu? I thought you couldn’t do anything without her.” “It didn’t used to be that way, but I guess it is now. And I’m comfortable with that. It’s good to be able to rely on others”
Ougi mocking him with Oshino’s line – “People can’t save people. I won’t save you. All you can do is save yourself on your own, Araragi.”
“It’s your uncle’s signature line. Not mine.”
Araragi doesn’t have regrets about helping people too much
“I detest things that are twisted around. I just want things to be proper.” Ougi attacks people’s hypocrisies and weaknesses
“You’ve matured, haven’t you.” Ougi so mocking
“Haven’t you grown up by giving up on lots of things?” “I don’t think that’s a bad thing.”
Beautiful shots in the forest
Yotsugi straight-up announcing Ougi’s the final boss
Great use of minimal colors – the night sky and the river versus the white of snow
Tadatsuru specializes in immortal apparitions that are dead
Discussing the creation of Yotsugi to the background of Yotsugi as an idol, then under the sea
Gorgeous colors here. Again, great use of Yotsugi’s color scheme in the background. Against skies, against flowers
“In the worst case, you can hand me over to save them”
Araragi flips her skirt in response. Playing the immature teen when he hears something he doesn’t want to acknowledge
He’ll distract Tadatsturu while Yotsugi rescues them
“I’ll be fine. I have my secret trump card: the grovel.”
A strategy meeting held entirely while Araragi holds up Yotsugi’s skirt
“You haven’t matured into an adult one bit.” Not willing to sacrifice anything except himself
Beautiful shot of them walking through a labyrinth from above
“You’ll end up murdering someone. If you do that, you really will stop being human.” “Humans are humans even if they kill others.”
Shinobu promises to make him fight and win if it seems like he’ll be killed, turning him into a vampire. It doesn’t matter to her if he’s a vampire
Kagenui and Tadatsuru apparently have a curse that keeps them from ever walking on the ground
“It’s more of a victim complex. According to the one that cast it on us, it’s merely ‘balancing the books’”
Tadatsuru: “Why in the world am I here?”
“I can’t shake the feeling I was cast in this role by someone else”
And the classic spotlight comes down
Tadatsuru is figuring out what’s actually happening, and taking it one concept at a time. Really nice idea
“If I knew where Oshino was, I wouldn’t have to do something this proper.” Echoing Ougi’s obsession
“I don’t want to help out in turning you into a vampire”
In order to avoid being used as a pawn to inadvertently turn Araragi into a vampire, Tadatsuru asks Yotsugi to kill him
“The reason why I killed him is because I’m a monster. Don’t end up like me, Araragi.”
Nice piano version of the OP
This time Araragi couldn’t win. But because of that, he still has the body of a human
And so his friendship with Yotsugi drifts apart
And he spends Valentine’s Day with Senjougahara
“Even if a mirror doesn’t show you, you will still be seen by my eyes.”
“Hanekawa doesn’t say you should be proper as much as before, right?” Okay with a messy life
“I was sitting inside the UFO catcher, and your sisters caught me”
Some things change, some things stay the same
It seemed like you liked the arc a lot more than your ANN review implied.
I feel totally vindicated in my previously expressed disappointment (https://wrongeverytime.com/2014/12/30/top-ten-anime-of-2014/ – comments) in Tsukimonogatari! I was worried you’d love it and give me good reasons to love it, too.
Hahaha. I mean, I wish I’d loved it, but I just didn’t see much to love in this one. Araragi arc + thematic retread + undercooked story doesn’t make for the best Monogatari.
I felt like this entire story was a drawn out “we’re spelling out exactly what’s wrong with Araragi, in case you weren’t paying attention before.” It just felt incredibly unnecessary.
Pretty much. Not much new here.
I’ve been told this arc is the one most hurt by the fact that Kizu has yet to be adapted. Since it deals heavily with his vampirism that sort of makes sense. Supposedly that resonance this arc was lacking is largely due to not knowing the details of Kizu. If only Kizu would come out we’d be able to actually see if that is the case.
Yeah, despite how much I love Monogatari overall, I feel sad, that something like Hana would spoil part of what I think that will make the next few arcs relevant, we’ve already seen a more mature Araragi, while someone as Hitagi is still a really insecure character, that needs the upcoming story to help herself and grow. Also I think that it didn’t help that this story was delivered as a stand alone.
It does seem like this one stands alone even worse than most of the arcs. And yeah, Hitagi could definitely use a more focused arc at this point. She’s only really been introduced so far, and still seems incredibly reliant on Araragi.
I agree that the arc wasn’t as great as many of the others by its own merit (many recent arcs have been really great self contained stories in addition to their role in the greater narrative) but I’d hardly call it much worse in the context of the show as a whole. Kaiki’s words to Araragi at the end of Koimonogatari essentially clarified to Araragi a huge issue in his behavior and this arc showed that he’s actually beginning to take a good look at his own problems, giving us the beginnings of what needs to be Araragi’s main character arc. It’s certainly not nearly as individually rewarding as many previous arcs (that also functioned well as a self contained story/character arc: Nekoshiro, Hanamonogatari, etc.) but that’s not its purpose.
Even if you accept that this arc was necessary to set up actual character growth (which I’d personally disagree with), we’ve already spent pretty much every Araragi arc having a front row seat to his issues and had Kaiki literally spell it out for us and him.
Araragi himself being enough of a screw-up that he needs another arc dedicated to spelling out his issues before anything can even start changing, does not make retreading all of this once again any more interesting for the audience.