Stepping back even further than Symphogear and Idolmaster, this week I reviewed the nameless moe beast itself, K-On! I was a firey young jerkoff the first time I watched K-On!, and dropped it a handful of episodes in, but this time I had a pretty good time with it. It wasn’t astonishingly good or anything, but it was a very enjoyable time, full of strong character animation and nice character-based gags. There were even a couple really heartfelt moments – most of these came from simple gestures of friendship between the characters, but the last, when Yui had to run to make it to their last performance, was a genuinely gripping sequence. K-On! probably won’t change your life, but it certainly works as a fuzzy temporary vacation from it.
You can check out my full review over at ANN, or my notes below!
Episode 1
Well damn. There’s already a great unexpected looseness to the animation here – it’s sharp, but the characters are visually expressive and exaggerated in a variety of ways. And the motion works well to convey personality and voice. Solid direction, too
Lots of visual humor that makes great use of timing. KyoAni are confident
And also great use of depth – multiple jokes at different planes at the same time
More dramatic direction for humorous effect as Yui approaches the school
Yui’s extremely visually expressive
This OP is really making me see how this show is nostalgia incarnate – from the priorities of the lyrics, to the relationships, to the very concept of a crappy high school pop band, everything here just emanates that ephemeral youthful feeling
Perky gag comedy timing. Perky soundtrack too, synths and chimes
Nodoka is Yui’s childhood friend
Yui’s faces lol
Yui’s tiny stick-hands are pretty great
Ritsu and Mio are introduced through body language in a variety of ways before their faces appear
More quick visual comedy, timing-based humor
Yui’s dopey face is a joke by itself
Ritsu faces too. They’ve got a very diverse look
These scene transitions are pretty interesting
More direction humor – this huge fisheye shot of the music room
And they’ve got Tsumugi
Yui the airhead MC is an interesting choice, but actually kinda perfect for this incredibly easygoing series
More fisheye shots as Mio and Ritsu react to Mugi saying she’s excited about fast food
We can already see Mugi’s deal – she’s delighted by small details of everyday life, because she’s clearly removed class-wise
More wacky wipe transitions
And more dramatic angles – crazy foreshortening on this shot from the corner of the band room, emphasizing the drums
oh my god, Yui’s memories of light music are just whacking a box on beat. she is the most useless person
“The club name has ‘light’ in it, so they probably just play easy music. Whistling and stuff”
oh my god these Yui daydreams are too much
Yui can barely walk down the friggin’ hall
The looseness of the show’s style at a distance is great – it doesn’t feel like the character designs made smaller, it feels like they’ve been more warped and stylized to better emphasize fundamental visual personality at a distance
Her slumping body language, dang
More synth tracks
Wacky-ass smears
More great body language. Very consistent character animation, but looser than KyoAni’s more recent stuff
Plying Yui with tea and cakes. lol
These faces are really something
Dang, I’m actually feeling kinda insecure with Yui here
“We can’t let this mark leave this room.”
oh my god, Ritsu kicking Mio. actually laughed out loud at that one. this show is really good
“What other things do you like?” “Anything that tastes good.” “Just food, huh”
Everyone being unimpressed with Yui is amazing
More great faces
This melty body language is wonderful
Shimmery late afternoon light on the tea and cakes. The afternoon idyll
These classic little movements as they set up for their song. So much mileage out of small tricks of pacing and character animation
This simple little song
“You guys really aren’t very good, are you. But it seems like a lot of fun!”
Oh my god, this photo. Combined nostalgia and humor – just Ritsu’s forehead
Sooo many faces
And more great details of body language
Episode 2
More Yui faces
Nodoka is basically Yui’s mom
Yui’s memories are all of her staring vaguely off into space. Yui is ridiculous
Jeez, the perspective in these shots is so exaggerated. It feels natural, but is incredibly stylized – a mix of the grounded backgrounds, heavy lighting, and well-animated but loose characters
Some of the jokes are a little too obvious – slow reactions, easy payoffs
Mugi’s apparently actually good at piano
All of their equipment is Mugi’s
In this episode, they’re all going way chibi in their reactions, and the other characters follow suit. A different style from the first episode, and definitely not a style I’ve regularly seen at KyoAni
Even the offhand expressions in the mid-distance shots are excellent. This show really cares about its visual language
“We’re like rare animals to her” re Mugi, which is true
Nice transition using the sound effects of Yui emptying her piggy bank
Yui can’t make it across the street without bumping into someone and being distracted by a dog. Yui is amazing
Diverse fashion for the character, a KyoAni staple
More silly synth songs
Mugi is very distinct from the rest of them. Although I guess they’re all distinct
Mugi getting really into them all getting part-time jobs
When the show goes for more dedicated gags, it’s often less effective than its simple incidental humor
Mio is Shy
Mio stealing herself is nice, because she’s also a derp – this whole plan is ridiculous, but her being invested demonstrates her derpness
Mugi is just fascinated by the job, while Yui’s trying to distract her
“People bring your family enough sweets that they go to waste?”
Absolutely lovely background colors
Yui returns their money, saying she’ll get a guitar within her means
Mugi’s dad is the company president, so she gets her guitar for basically nothing
“I gotta practice signing my autograph!”
Aaand now she’s sleeping with her guitar
A sense of import to Yui first plugging in her guitar
Episode 3
Mio’s gap moe is pretty extreme. I’m not surprised she became a poster girl for moe blobs
Lots of light incidental jokes. The show is at its best when the jokes come naturally like this, at least so far
“It’s not like you’ve studied for a single test since middle school.” “Oh right! Then it’s all good”
I like this half synth, half organ song
Yui feels betrayed that Ritsu didn’t screw up on the test
The backgrounds are nice – those classic seemingly penciled KyoAni ones for the longer shots
Yui’s banned from club activities until she passes her make-ups, meaning they all have to help her pass
That quick transition to Yui just strumming away on her chords. As usual, excellent comedic timing
Mio sends her such a formal message, lol
The animation isn’t always ostentatious, but it has great personality
And then they meet Ui, Yui’s actually put-together sister
A lot of the jokes are essentially “harmless,” which fits, since this is such a grounded show. They’re actual jokes that would come up between friends, not comedy jokes
Ritsu’s just distracting Yui, lol
This Ritsu gag is pretty great
More cute casual conversations
And now Yui gets into some ridiculous daydreams
Yui going black and white and loosely drawn after the test. More nice understated visual gags
Yui forgot all her chords, lol
Episode 4
Beach episode
The backgrounds here can’t quite match up to their recent shows
Yui and Ritsu really bring out the silliest in each other
Rapport is the cornerstone of this show
Mio checks out the club’s old materials
Lol, this summer vacation song
The animation’s more about personality than fluidity
Man, the instruments sure are nicely drawn
“Mugi… do you have a summer house?”
Yui’s bedhead is pretty great
Dang, this shot from the seagull’s perspective
This whole soundtrack is so dorky – smooth beach jams
Then again, I guess this whole show is basically a vacation. Peaceful time with friends
“I could only borrow our smallest house”
Mugi feels embarrassed about her rich lifestyle. She just wants things to be normal with her normal friends
Mugi and Mio sharing a moment regarding the old club
And then Yui and Ritsu interrupt them with derp
Watermelons and everything
Awesome foreshortening on this shot of Mugi waking them up
Ritsu and Yui being useless
More great atmospheric shots – the evening scene framed through Yui’s footsteps
This scene with Mio watching Yui play is magical
Mio’s too much. Her character is so inherently exaggerated. It’s kind of off-putting
Holy crap, Yui can play now. Dear lord
So many good faces
I remember the first time I watched this episode, I basically assumed Mio and Yui would be a couple based on the tonal choices here. But apparently this director just super loves framing relationships in the most romantically charged context without actually going anywhere with it. Fun
Episode 5
The old light music club pictures
And now meeting Sawako-sensei
Yui just being a lump
This sappy flashback for Ritsu forgetting to submit the club application form
They’re basically a coordinated comedy troupe when they want to be. Looney Tunes language
Wow, this Sawako sequence is great
This episode is also really heavy on stark lighting – heavy shadows, oversaturated light. Kind of a weird fit for K-On!
“You’re still dragging out that shtick?”
The show can be really grounded in its humor, but it can also completely lean into particularly silly gags
Lots of sweat drops in this episode, too
Mugi defends with cake!
Mugi’s got a nice counterpoint silliness to Yui and Ritsu
So I guess Mugi’s gay? Kinda odd that they’re just offhand implying that, since it’s not going anywhere. Nice if that’s just actually what they’re doing, then
“I love these lyrics! I think they’re great!”
Yep, Mugi’s just yuri goggles all day
“Maybe I can give my image a boost by saying that I like this perky, cutesy crap” amazing
So many little animation gags
“You don’t think that Mugi has a thing for Sawako-sensei, huh?” “Oh, no. It’s just nice to see some girl-on-girl action.”
“If the people involved are happy with it, it’s alright, right?” Huh! So it really is just sort of an offhand thing. Nice
This episode actually had a fair amount of stuff happen – the form, advisor search, and vocals stuff
Episode 6
Sawako’s gags seem to be a bit more “anime” than some of the others
Carrying instruments sure does suck
These lovely peaceful establishing shots for tea-time
More derpy organ songs
Great character animation for Ritsu. All of them have different body language
Ritsu working to calm down Mio in her own way
Nodoka looking on, hoping Yui can finally succeed in something
Cute little music video thing for their performance. Nice classic color filters
And Yui’s terrible backing vocals are a nice touch
goddamnit Mio
Episode 7
TINY YUI OMG
Christmas episode, I guess
Ui keeping Yui alive for forever
“I haven’t been very good, so maybe he won’t come” lol
Yui has the tiniest feet
Yui ripped up a cushion to make it a white Christmas for Ui. Adorable little moment
Incredibly cute moment of the sisters sharing warm things on the way to school. Very true to each of them, with Yui doing her silly best to be a good big sister. These are the moments where the series shines
More wacky faces, loose animation focused on cute keyframes
“Leave the food to me, because Ui will be making it.”
Ritsu and Yui see how excited Mugi is about a normal christmas and smile at each other. Her personality’s infectious
Ui commits to everything she does
Mugi turns down a trip to Hawaii to get a board game to play with her friends. Mugi in a nutshell – she’s a simple type, but it’s played in an endearing way, not for direct jokes
Yui versus the sandwiches. Another good tiny visual gag
“She tried to clean up the house and tried to put up decorations.” Ui’s sad defences of Yui
Sawako again getting the most “anime” jokes – a single woman one and a cosplay gag
And of course Ui and Yui somehow get each other the right presents
“Mio-chan really pushed herself there” lol
And Mugi just makes a ridiculous face
This was basically an Ui and Yui episode, and really strong because of it
“Give me Ui-chan!”
The show actually generally avoids anime-ism jokes, but not with Sawako
Episode 8
Yui being the embarrassing sister at Ui’s exam results
And there’s Azusa
Mio getting sassy about Ritsu being in a different class
Yui and Ui again. The show consistently repeats basic jokes, but they’re more texture than actual gags. It’s very much a mood piece
Really nice shots stranding Mio alone for this class gag
“Come to the Light Music Club, where you get all the tea and snacks you want, and do nothing but eat and sleep!”
Yui’s friggin’ chicken outfit
Ritsu’s just lying on the couch in her maid outfit
More nicely loose animation for Sawa dragging Mio around
Mio’s technically the “straight man,” but she’s so easily defeated she can’t really do anything
Another nice shot framed to emphasize Azusa’s walk up into the club room. This episode’s director is strong
They immediately change out of maid outfits and into track suits, because lol playing music in a maid outfit
Ui’s friend also struggling to have nice things to say about the Light Music Club
“The Light Music Club is a blast!” a lot of the fun is how happy the characters are
“Fun is fun!”
Another nice shot – floor level, in the midst of the instruments as they set up
“My Love is a Stapler” good song title
Really nice colors for this scene. The stage lights and curtains bring out the base colors of the band
Oh wow, this transition from the guitar bit to Mio picking up the vocals is fantastic
Azusa staring intently is great. This song’s catchy, too
Haha, this shot with Mugi framed between the three of them staring out the door
Episode 9
Yui excited about being a senpai
ono, don’t let Azusa be even more helpless than Mio
Ritsu throwing a still frame of Yui is great
Azusa surprised by what worthless derps they all are
Lots of silly rose backgrounds for effects here
Yui just pets her into submission, lol
Yui’s slow collapse with her guitar, nice animation and vocal performance
Tempting Azusa with cakes. Great gags. These girls are terrible
She already seems like a more dedicated straight man than Mio
Oh god, Sawako got her cat ears
“Your nickname has to be Azu-nyan!” oh god
Mio just feels relieved she’s not being bullied anymore
Mio versus the cat ears. Beautiful
Mio actually checking if Azusa’s okay. Good to see
This is honestly kinda uncomfortable. These guys are not good friends to Azusa. And in a show so focused on being comfy, that’s a problem
The show is basically entirely loose on the actual music – proficiency is based on humor expediency
“These other bands are all better than the Light Music Club, so why?” Gotta have that K-On magic
Nice, they’re resolving these conflicts immediately and with empathy
Episode 10
Ui just sees her sister as a kind of pet
Nice early evening shot in the room
Mio still doesn’t realize Mugi’s just a quieter kind of derp
Breezy beach montage
Yui doesn’t know what a tuner is, she just easily does it by ear. Pretty classic Yui
Yui and Ritsu have so many gags specific to the two of them. You rarely see such an even “friends with similar senses of humor” dynamic
Mio is too easy
Wow, this face for Mio
Sawako even tries to do a boob grab joke
Yui’s practicing after everyone else has gone to sleep
Nice little scene of Yui and Azusa
Episode 11
Dang, great shot of the school reflected to open this episode
Azusa’s gotten pretty comfortable with the group dynamic
Yeah, it’s immediately clear the dynamic has changed this episode. Azusa’s part of the group now
And now the dynamic is way stronger. Azusa as the more coherent straight man really helps the team
“Why did you get that guitar? It’s heavy, and it’s got a thick neck…” “I got it because it’s cute!”
“You charge for this?” lol
Some drama with Mio apparently
Ritsu is jealous of Mio being friends with Nodoka
Jeez, Ritsu’s a jerk!
Mugi suggests tea!
Yep, Ritsu’s feeling sad because she’s not Mio’s favorite. Drama out of friggin’ nowhere!
This show sure isn’t good at this
Sawako suggests looking for a replacement drummer. She sure is good at leaning into the worst parts of the show
ah good, this makeup scene is excellent
“You’re a good egg!” that is a perfectly K-On! line
Episode 12
And this episode opens with Yui eating Mugi’s eyebrows. Good start
Yui’s sick
Yui apparently got too good while she was sick
lol, it’s actually Ui
Who can apparently play guitar better than Yui just after holding her guitar a few times
Yui sneezes on the camera
“You’re finally kicking me out?!” like she’s been expecting it, lol
“I’m gonna sleep a lot. I’m gonna sleep as much as I can!” you can do it Yui
Tiny Yui’s stupid haircut is perfect
Really cute moment with Yui and Azusa
A nice repeat of the first episode’s opening sequence for Yui running to her performance, but now she has actual purpose
Nicely contrasted with some lovely animation for Mio’s song
“You’ll find them soon enough. You’ll find something you can do. Something you can lose yourself in. And a place that means more than anything to you.” Dang, this is really good
“We all think you’re the greatest, Yui”
damn, reaaaally strong episode
“Right now, for us, this auditorium is our Budokan!”
Mugi opens a final jam and encore. So good
This episode kinda elevates the series. What a good finale
OVA 1 (actually an extra episode that did air, apparently)
Lots of feet and legs in this opening. Who’s the director who likes feet, again
Really nice long shots too, and a very nice song
They’re absolutely nailing the tone of early winter morning
“You are a disappointment!” to her gloves. lol
Glovington
Azusa’s bag says “Pet Shop Girls,” which is a cute reference
Mugi amazed about submitting her time card for her part time job
Ritsu reading what sounds like a love letter
Really, really nice quiet scenes this episode
Azusa yawning in time with the cat is adorable
And Yui sends a bizarre upbeat text when they’re all having a hard time, giving each of them the help they need. Yui’s basically the Gon of their group – the sun
Of course, the “love letter” was just lyrics from Mio
“You’re so lucky! I wish we could install one of you in our house!”
“Hey, does it cost a lot to rent the Budokan?”
OVA 2
A show opportunity on the last day of the year at an actual club
Meeting the other bands
Mio’s got a fan
Designing a tea-time logo
Deciding on the lighting styles for their songs
Yui consulting the punk band on everything, lol
They somehow still manage to have a tea break in the backstage room
All of them just milling uselessly around on stage
Sawako runs into an old band friend
Even here, the song cuts back to their clubroom. That’s basically the little perfect world this show revolves around
Ui once again made happy just pandering her sister
This show is a very successful self-contained nostalgia engine! It feels sad to leave this atmosphere behind
Given the last few seasons of anime, I’m sure you could go watch a LOT of the lesser and overblown anime of yesteryear with fresh appreciation.
Yup, this is my take on the show as well. It’s not interested in a story, but it’s interested in an atmosphere, and that atmosphere is nostalgia.
I said so on Twitter, but when you think about it, I think Hyouka shares a lot of the same atmosphere. Sure, it’s a lot more driven by questions of friendship, self-worth, how to relate to one another, and the “plottiness” means it’s not as “atmospherically-driven,” but a lot of what makes Hyouka such a lived-in experience is the same “nostalgia-atmosphere” treatment.
I like how the show emphasizes this by having most of their performances visually center themselves on the places that created their music – the school in general and their club room in particular. It feels like the closed atmosphere of that particular room is the show’s main “character.”
You know, it’s true, the club room is a character, but not just as a where, but as a when, which is what nostalgia revolves around. I mean, Kyoukai no Kanata was often at its best within the clubroom. Hyouka’s main story/theme may not have been “club-centered”, but the atmosphere is what carried the show.
As “pure clubroom activity” shows, I do think K-On! is the best I’ve seen, but then again, I mostly avoid this type of show so there could be better ones out there.
Also, if you think about it like that, so many of the KyoAni shows could be defined as “clubroom shows”, not just overtly, but about a where-when being a strong character.
Missed opportunity for a Journey pun.