Love Hina was a legitimately formative experience for me, and Negima! also an off-kilter favorite, so it was pretty much inevitable that I eventually check out Akamatsu’s most recent manga. Unfortunately, so far this investigation has not been rewarded – UQ Holder has been a slog, frankly, possessing none of the creativity or hooks that made his last work fairly reliably rewarding. And this one doesn’t even start off pretending it’s a harem – it jumps straight into shounen territory, but that shounen is just not at all entertaining. Negima! has demonstrated Akamatsu can do some fantastic things in this genre, so hopefully UQ Holder finds its feet eventually.
You can check out my full review over at ANN, or my chapter notes below!
Chapter 1
Right, the story is about a family of immortals
The CG backgrounds can lack in personality at times
And the character designs are maybe a bit too standardized
“Polish” is absolutely the word for Akamatsu’s style. That and reliability
The incidental slapstick humor. The world is always kinda loose
Tota’s the lead, Kuromaru is his friend
Karin is the new girl
Tota is the opposite of Negi. He’s the classic optimistic, thick-headed, go-getter shounen hero
Chapter 2
Some decent white-black contrast in a couple of these pages, but the art here is far more functional than beautiful
The slapstick momentum is good, though
Tota’s weakness is that if his body parts are separated but not destroyed, they remain that way
Chapter 3
Moving from a big test to training. The story knows how to keep momentum going
Good momentum and sense of weight to the fight scenes
Jinbei Shishido, who’s been immortal for 1400 years
His type of immortality isn’t particularly strong
Many of the scenes, particularly in fights, just lack backgrounds altogether
Seeking a weapon. Another chapter hook. Chapters aren’t built around full stories but around moving from one hook to the next
Chapter 4
Evangeline characteristically forgot she’d condemned her group’s leader to the sewers two years ago
Some good quick gags here
The CG setpieces are a little underwhelming
A sword that can multiply its own weight
A month of training montage and he can wield it at two thousand-fold weight
Chapter 5
“I have received no orders from Yukihime-sama to smile” lol
Nice spread of the whole group showing off their monstrous nature
Chapter 6
The scale of some of the big shots is very impressive. This spread of the slums is very good
The fight shots here are also pretty compelling, though there’s not much of a sense of tension. Negima’s best fights worked because of tactics and character investment, and we’re not there with either here
Fights are also often obscured through too much effects usage and explosions
Chapter 7
Aaaand another random sensei shows up. Hrm
Chapter 8
Some super fun gender essentialism nonsense in this chapter
Reading up to the latest chapter, so far it doesn’t seem to get any better. I’m still sticking with it because it knows polish and momentum, but it hasn’t find any substance yet. Not to mention it eventually resorts back to harem shenanigans I thought Akamatsu has grown tired of. I’m still hopeful it’ll regain at least some of Negima’s spark when the Tournament arc actually begins though.