Hello folks, and welcome back to Wrong Every Time. Alongside the week’s usual scattering of films and videogames (in spite of my grumbling, I am still bashing my head against Hades 2), this week saw us screening the first three episodes of Critical Role’s fourth campaign, which trades out their usual DM Matt Mercer for Dimension 20’s Brennan Lee Mulligan, alongside essentially doubling the table size to a total of thirteen rotating players. All of this sounded like it might amplify the inherently confusing, unwieldy nature of Critical Role’s live sessions, but the results have been astonishing; to be honest, this campaign has so far been the most compelling D&D project I’ve ever witnessed.
Mulligan’s strategy of breaking his sessions into concrete scenes has made for a far more propulsive, coherent ride than the CR standard, the world they are revealing feels substantive, lived-in, and rich in thematic implications, and the cast are inhabiting a dynamite array of characters, successfully rallying back from the “everyone’s trying to be Jester” doldrums of campaign three. Mulligan’s influence and the cast’s clear renewed enthusiasm have turned Critical Role into genuine appointment television, and if you’ve never seen a live play before, I’d say this is a fine chance to see what peak performance looks like. Regardless, I have of course made time for more of our regularly scheduled movie screenings, so let’s break down some films in the Week in Review!