Buckle in folks, it’s time for more Chihayafuru! We return in the midst of another tense tournament sequence, as both Taichi and Arata separately battle for the right to challenge the current karuta Master. However, claiming that karuta crown might be the least of Taichi’s worries at the moment, or at least, just one potential solution to his current anxieties. As Taichi faces his toughest opponents ever, with Harada too burnt out to support him and only Hanano defending him from his mother’s rage, he seems to also be at last facing down the emotional conflicts that have consistently haunted his relationship with both Chihaya and karuta. With only this tournament remaining before he must dedicate himself fully to a pre-med career track, Taichi is finally asking himself what he truly wants, and who he wants to be.

These are difficult questions for any teenager to answer, and in Taichi’s case, his inability to articulate and pursue what he truly wants has been Chihayafuru’s most intractable emotional conflict for the majority of its run.  Whether he truly loves Chihaya or is simply infatuated with her, whether he’s genuinely passionate about karuta, whether there’s even a path he can follow if he wants to continue the sport at the highest level – these questions have been percolating for three seasons now, and it’s both gratifying to see Taichi at last acknowledging he needs to answer these questions, and thrilling to wonder at where he’ll move from his current stasis.

It’s also a little worrying, to be honest, largely because of Chihayafuru’s overarching strengths and weaknesses, as well as its specific genre-melding compromises. The Chihaya-Taichi-Arata love triangle has consistently been Chihayafuru’s weakest element, and has hung on a certain style of fantastical “destined love” inevitability that feels dramatically and emotionally unconvincing, particularly in the context of the show’s far stronger reflections on personal anxiety and identity. On top of that, the question of whether Arata truly loves karuta is complicated by the fact that Chihayafuru has one foot in classic sports dramas, where total obsession with some sport is a base dramatic assumption, and one foot in coming-of-age character dramas, where “hyper-obsession over one pastime to the exclusion of all else” isn’t actually a healthy attitude. How the show will navigate both the base dramatic/emotional complexity of this situation, as well as how it intersects with the show’s traditional weaknesses, is a question that has me equally thrilled and nervous for whatever’s next. Either way, I love Chihayafuru, I’m happy to see Taichi engaging with these questions, and I’m eager to see where we go from here. LET’S GET TO IT!

Continue reading →

Well folks, somehow we’re in it all over again. After the tense conclusion of the pre-Masters tournament left Chihaya elated and Taichi in despair, Chihayafuru wasted only seven or eight minutes handling the post-tournament cooldown, before immediately ramping up into the next tournament’s preamble. At this point, Chihayafuru’s overarching narrative seems to be rising up the curve of drama you generally expect from each individual arc, except applied to the show as a whole – arcs don’t really “cool down” anymore, since we’re actually approaching the story’s overarching dramatic crescendo. And with Tsutomu having made clear how high the stakes are for Taichi at this point, it feels like we really might be approaching Chihayafuru’s ultimate climax, or at least a meaningful relational shift from all that has come before.

The plain fact of it is, Taichi just can’t keep doing this to himself. In emotional terms, he’s spent his entire high school career pining for his best friend, and even making her passion his own, all without ever telling her how he feels. This situation is unhealthy for Taichi and unfair for Chihaya, and as time has gone on, it seems he’s only gotten even more emotionally dependent on her. In practical terms, we’re approaching the end of our heroes’ second high school year, and if Taichi’s planning on actually pursuing a pre-med path, he can’t possibly maintain this level of karuta study. Something has to give soon, and though I hope that “something” involves coming clean with Chihaya, I’m not sure Taichi is capable of taking that step. However things shake out, this is bound to be a tournament loaded with emotional baggage, as Taichi’s balancing act is strained to the breaking point. LET’S GET TO IT!

Continue reading →

THE BATTLE CONTINUES. As we return to Chihayafuru, Chihaya and Taichi remain locked in a finals bout that could dictate not just the course of their karuta fortunes, but also their personal relationship, and perhaps even their futures altogether. I don’t expect this battle to outright resolve any elements of this show’s central relationship drama, but it seems almost guaranteed to provoke meaningful changes on that front. Chihaya has never been forced to acknowledge Taichi so directly, and seeing the two of them up there has apparently provoked even Arata to find some small shard of jealousy within himself.

Beyond its emotional consequences, this bout has also been one of Chihayafuru’s most tactically gripping and aesthetically impressive matches so far, and I’m eager to get back to it. I preambled the heck out of this fight last time, so I hope you’ll forgive me if we dive directly into the action this time. LET’S GET TO THE MATCH!

Continue reading →